Introduction
In an era of instant digital information, streaming entertainment, and artificial intelligence, the traditional book may appear to be a relic of a bygone age. With knowledge available at the tap of a screen and attention spans shrinking, some argue that books have lost their relevance and serve no meaningful purpose in the modern world. This essay examines the case for this provocative claim.
Digital media provides faster, more accessible, and more up-to-date information than books.
Explain
In a world that demands real-time information, books are inherently limited by their static nature. By the time a non-fiction book is researched, written, edited, and published, the information it contains may already be outdated. Digital sources such as websites, databases, and online journals can be updated continuously.
Example
Medical professionals increasingly rely on digital databases like UpToDate and PubMed rather than textbooks for clinical decision-making, as medical knowledge doubles approximately every 73 days. Singapore's Ministry of Education has also shifted toward digital learning resources, with the Student Learning Space platform supplementing and sometimes replacing traditional textbooks.
Link
This demonstrates that in fields where currency and accessibility of information matter, books serve a diminished purpose compared to their digital alternatives.
Modern entertainment and narrative media have surpassed books in engagement and reach.
Explain
Television series, films, video games, and podcasts now offer immersive storytelling experiences with visual, auditory, and interactive dimensions that books cannot match. These media attract far larger audiences, particularly among younger generations, suggesting that books are no longer the primary vehicle for narrative engagement.
Example
Netflix's global subscriber base exceeded 260 million in 2024, while global book sales have stagnated. In Singapore, a 2019 National Reading Habits Survey found that the average Singaporean read only about four books per year, with younger respondents increasingly preferring video content and social media for leisure.
Link
The declining share of books in the entertainment landscape suggests that their purpose as a primary medium for storytelling and leisure is being eroded by more engaging alternatives.
The environmental cost of physical book production undermines their purpose in an eco-conscious world.
Explain
The printing industry consumes vast quantities of paper, water, and energy, contributing to deforestation and carbon emissions. In a modern world increasingly concerned with sustainability, the continued mass production of physical books is difficult to justify when digital alternatives exist.
Example
The US book industry consumes approximately 32 million trees annually, and a single book requires an estimated 7.5 kilogrammes of carbon dioxide to produce. E-readers such as the Kindle, while having their own environmental footprint, offset this impact after approximately 20 to 25 books, making them more sustainable for avid readers.
Link
From an environmental standpoint, the purpose of physical books is increasingly questionable when more sustainable digital alternatives are available.
Counter-Argument
Books foster deep reading, sustained concentration, and empathy in ways that digital media cannot replicate. Research by Maryanne Wolf found that print readers demonstrated significantly better comprehension and retention than screen readers, and literary fiction has been shown to improve Theory of Mind, the ability to understand others' mental states.
Rebuttal
While books may offer cognitive benefits, these advantages do not mean books are the only or best medium for all purposes. Digital platforms provide faster, more accessible, and continuously updated information that books cannot match, and the declining readership rates, with the average Singaporean reading only four books per year, suggest that books' purpose is already being fulfilled more effectively by alternative media for most people.
Conclusion
While there are grounds to argue that books have been supplanted in many of their traditional functions by faster, more accessible digital alternatives, the claim that they serve no purpose at all is an overstatement. Nevertheless, the declining centrality of books in information and entertainment is an undeniable modern trend.
Introduction
Despite the proliferation of digital media and alternative forms of information, books continue to serve vital intellectual, cultural, and personal purposes that no other medium can fully replicate. To declare books purposeless in the modern world is to fundamentally misunderstand their enduring value. This essay argues that books remain indispensable even in the digital age.
Books foster deep reading and sustained concentration that digital media cannot replicate.
Explain
Reading a book requires sustained, focused attention that develops critical thinking, analytical skills, and the capacity for complex thought. Digital media, with its constant notifications, hyperlinks, and algorithmic distractions, encourages shallow skimming rather than deep engagement.
Example
Research by Maryanne Wolf of UCLA found that readers of print books demonstrated significantly better comprehension and retention than those who read the same material on screens. In Singapore, the National Library Board's 'Read! Singapore' initiative continues to promote book reading specifically for its cognitive benefits, reflecting an institutional recognition that books serve a unique intellectual purpose.
Link
This demonstrates that books serve the essential purpose of training and sustaining the human capacity for deep, focused thought, a purpose that is arguably more important than ever in our distracted digital age.
Books are irreplaceable repositories of cultural heritage and collective memory.
Explain
Books preserve the intellectual and cultural achievements of civilisations in a durable, permanent form. Unlike digital content, which can be deleted, altered, or rendered inaccessible by technological obsolescence, books endure for centuries and provide an unalterable record of human thought and creativity.
Example
The works of Shakespeare, first published in the 1623 First Folio, remain in print and continue to shape global literature and theatre over 400 years later. In Singapore, the National Library's rare books collection, including early accounts of the region such as Abdullah bin Abdul Kadir's 'Hikayat Abdullah,' preserves irreplaceable records of the nation's pre-independence history and Malay literary heritage.
Link
The purpose of books as enduring vessels of cultural heritage is one that no digital medium has yet proven capable of fulfilling with the same permanence and reliability.
Books develop empathy and emotional intelligence in ways uniquely suited to the medium.
Explain
Literary fiction, in particular, requires readers to inhabit the perspectives and inner lives of characters different from themselves, building empathy and understanding. This immersive, reflective engagement with others' experiences is facilitated by the slow, contemplative nature of reading in ways that faster media do not encourage.
Example
A landmark study published in the journal Science by David Comer Kidd and Emanuele Castano found that reading literary fiction significantly improved readers' ability to understand others' mental states, a skill known as Theory of Mind. This finding underpins Singapore's emphasis on literature in the school curriculum, where texts like Singaporean author Suchen Christine Lim's 'The River's Song' are studied for their exploration of identity and empathy.
Link
This unique capacity to cultivate empathy confirms that books serve a vital purpose in developing the emotional and social intelligence necessary for a compassionate modern society.
Counter-Argument
Digital media provides faster, more up-to-date information than books, modern entertainment media attract far larger audiences, and the environmental cost of printing 32 million trees annually in the US alone is difficult to justify when digital alternatives exist.
Rebuttal
Speed and reach are not the only measures of purpose. Books serve irreplaceable functions in preserving cultural heritage for centuries, as Shakespeare's First Folio demonstrates, and in training the human capacity for deep, sustained thought that digital media's constant notifications and algorithmic distractions actively undermine. Singapore's National Library Board continues to promote book reading precisely because these cognitive and cultural purposes cannot be replicated by screens.
Conclusion
In conclusion, books continue to serve irreplaceable purposes in fostering deep thinking, preserving cultural heritage, and nurturing empathy and imagination. Far from being purposeless, they remain a cornerstone of intellectual and cultural life in the modern world, complementing rather than being replaced by digital media.